Power and Leadership: Reflecting on Policing and Effective Leadership

June 21, 2008

Learning the way power and leadership are misaligned

Today, my daughter and I shared a thought-provoking moment while driving. We noticed two police cars strategically hidden behind a sign, diligently clocking speeders with radar guns. It got me thinking about an essential aspect of power and leadership – the use of power and the impact it has on individuals and communities.

The Hidden Police Cars: An Unexpected Lesson in Power and Leadership

A Surprising Perspective

I turned to my daughter and asked her a simple yet profound question, “Why do they hide behind signs to catch people speeding, instead of being out in the open, reminding people to adhere to the speed limit?” Her response was surprisingly insightful, “Power,” she said, and proceeded to share what she had learned about how the role of the police has evolved over time.

Power and Leadership: The Evolving Role of Law Enforcement

She talked about a time when the police were more like the friendly neighbor next door, akin to Andy Griffith in Mayberry. They were actively engaged in the community, helping and supporting, rather than primarily focused on catching people unaware and issuing tickets.

Contrasting Experiences: Policing and the MS150 Bike Rid

Encouragement vs. Enforcement

This led me to share an experience my wife and I had during the MS150 Bike ride this year. We encountered police officers who were stopping traffic to provide us with encouragement and support along the way. It was a stark contrast to the hidden police cars clocking speeders.

The Power Dilemma

The question that lingered in my mind was whether it’s the specific situation that dictates how the police show up or if there has been a fundamental shift in their approach. Are they using their power to feel better about themselves and their roles, or have the risks they face in their line of duty led to a heightened sense of caution that sometimes comes across as overly assertive? Could it be a matter of their internal self-image?

Lessons for Leadership

Context and Leadership

As leaders, we can draw valuable lessons from this reflection. How we approach leadership is undoubtedly influenced by the situations we find ourselves in and our past experiences. Just as the police officers’ behavior may be shaped by the context and the changing nature of their roles, our leadership style may also adapt based on circumstances.

The Power-Compassion Balance

But the question remains – is the use of power always an effective way to lead? The balance between authority and empathy, assertiveness and compassion, is delicate. Effective leadership often involves understanding when to assert authority and when to employ empathy, when to be assertive and when to be compassionate.

Implications for Executive Coaching

The Human Aspect of Leadership

In the world of executive coaching and leadership development, these reflections have significant implications. The ability to navigate complex leadership situations while maintaining authenticity and empathy is a hallmark of great leaders. It requires a deep understanding of the human aspect of leadership, as well as a willingness to adapt to changing circumstances.

Adaptation, Power and Leadership

In conclusion, our discussion about the hidden police cars and their use of power offers us a valuable insight into the nuances of leadership. Just as the police force evolves to meet the demands of their role, so must leaders adapt to the ever-changing landscape of their organizations and communities. Effective leadership goes beyond power; it’s about understanding, empathy, and the ability to connect with others on a human level.

Reach your next peak

We help leaders expand the change they want to see in their teams, organizations, and the wider world.